The local St Kitts Nevis Observer newspaper described the attacker as wielding a machete.
About 9 p.m. ET last Thursday night, Justice Breyer, his wife and houseguests were robbed by one person, wearing a mask and wielding a knife, a court official said. The robber made off with about $1,000 in cash.
No one was hurt in the incident.
Previously filed financial disclosure forms as well as articles and tourist websites acknowledge that Justice Breyer is a regular vacationer to the island and has owned a home there for quite some time.
The Nevis police department is investigating and says there are no suspects or arrests at this time.
Local news reports as well as the police acknowledge other robberies and break-ins in the area around the same time.
It’s the third time in recent years that a Supreme Court justice has been a crime victim.
Back in 2004, Justice David Souter suffered minor injuries when he was mugged by a group of young men while jogging.
And in 1996, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg had her purse snatched near the Kennedy Center while walking with her husband and daughter. She was not hurt in the incident.
Crime in the Carribbean, and partcularly on Nevis, has climbed dramatically in recent years, according to the United Nations.
Over the past year, Americans living on Nevis say they’ve had enough of the frequent home invasions.
One American expatriate, who no longer wants to be named because he says he’s been harassed by local officials, started his own crime-reporting service for people on the island, because residents claim police are inadequate.
Last year citizens met with police, and staged a rally, to try to call attention to the crime problem.
People are furious, according to NBC News. Some Americans who own properties on the island no longer want to retire there because of the crime — and they say the crime rate has lowered their property values.
Mike Kosnar, Michelle Kosinski and Pete Williams contributed to this report.